Copyright © 2001 by Creation Research Society. All rights reserved.
Scanning Electron Microscope Study of Mummified Collagen Fibers in Fossil Tyrannosaurus rex Bone
CRSQ Vol 38 No 2 pp 61-66 September 2001
A specimen of hip bone from a Tyrannosaurus rex,
excavated from a ranch in Wyoming over 100 years ago, and thought to be
65 million years old is shown, by scanning electron microscopy, to have
intact, mummified microscopic collagen fibers and other ultrastructural
features within compact bone. Bone Haversian canals as well as lacunae
and canaliculi are well preserved. Networks of collagen fibers remain
intact within lacunae and what may be mummified osteocytes are shown to
be present. Twenty-year-old, similarly fractured natural human hip bone
shows comparable patterns of canals, collagen networks and cells, including
crenated erythrocytes. Hip bone from Moab man, human remains
collected from Utah and thought to be less than 200 years old, contains
no such soft tissue features within compact bone. Moab man specimens appear
cleanly stripped of soft tissues and harbor burrowing insect remains.
These data call into question the long ages ascribed to these dinosaur
fossils and support their rapid preservation in the absence of decomposers.
The high level of ultrastructural preservation also implies that these
dinosaur bones are simply not very old.
The remarkable preservation of macro and microscopic structures of fossils in general and fossilized dinosaur bones in particular, has been the subject of many creationist books, articles and reviews (Calais, 1994; Helder, 1992; Howe, 1997; Taylor, 1999; Weiland, 1997b).
What appear to be red blood cells have been described from Tyrannosaurus rex bones (Weiland 1997a), while other dinosaur bones have been found which cannot be distinguished from modern bone (Weiland, 1999). Additionally, soft muscles, internal organs and even microscopic fibers have been well preserved in a juvenile dinosaur recovered in China (Snelling 1998).
In some of these writings it is often charged or implied by creationists that evolutionists are reluctant to make these startling revelations, even in recent times because it does not support their position that these fossils are over 65 million years old, or that they took millions of years to fossilize. Although the process of fossilization is not completely understood, it is assumed by both evolutionists and creationists that most fossils must be buried or stabilized very quickly in order to stand any chance of being preserved. Briggs states: Of course fossilization is time dependent. But although the age of most fossils is measured in millions of years (and some diagenic processes are certainly long term), whether or not an organism is destined to become a fossil may be determined very rapidly (Briggs, 1995). Mineralized and petrified oddities such as bowler hats, fencing wire and sacks of flour (Walker, 2000; Weiland 2000) certainly show us that fossilization can take place quite rapidly, freezing the feeding practice or even the process of giving birth, forever into rock.
It is incorrect, however, to state that evolutionists have not been forthcoming with data that may show that fossilization and mineralization of biological materials can happen so rapidly as to preserve microscopic structures. As early as 1962 these scientists have shown that microscopic structures, such as bone collagen are well preserved in dinosaur bones (Little, Kelly and Courts, 1962). This work was followed by a series of studies by Pawlicki and his associates demonstrating by scanning and transmission electron microscopy that not only were collagen fibers found in dinosaur bones (thought to be 80 million or more years old), but that blood vessels, osteocytes (bone building cells) and even intact proteins, lipids, mucopolysaccharides and DNA were found (Pawlicki, Korbel and Kubiak, 1966; Pawicki, 1975; 1977a; b; 1985; 1995). There are also good data in the literature that rapid fossilization of soft body structures may occur under certain anoxic or pH regulated (low pH level) conditions (Briggs and Kear 1993a; 1993b; Briggs, 1995). Experimental taphonomy (the study of the transition of organic remains from biosphere to lithosphere) is ongoing in many paleontology laboratories. To quote Briggs (1995, pp. 539, 544), Unless the morphology of the most labile tissues is stabilized before the decay (within days or weeks) nothing remains The results demonstrate that replication of soft-tissue can take place within weeks, even where the only major source of the phosphate is the carcass itself. They also show that the closure of the system is as important, at least in some cases, as the absence of oxygen.
In addition, some paleontologists are quite candid about the fact that the excellent preservation in many fossils must mean that fossilization or burial was instantaneous (Martill, 1989, p. 204). Martill even demonstrated muscle banding and cell nuclei in highly magnified fossilized fish muscle and stated that phosphatization (mineralization) must have been complete within a few (probably less than 5) hours. Thus, for over 40 years evolutionist workers have reported openly on the presence of such remarkable preservation in dinosaur and other fossils.
In this study, fossilized bone from a T. rex dinosaur recovered from a dig at New Castle, Wyoming was evaluated for the presence of microscopic cells, vessels and fibers under the scanning electron microscope. These results were compared to recent human hipbone fragments supplied by an anatomical supply company and human hip fragments from a mine at Moab, Utah.
Materials and Methods
This study examined a museum specimen of T. rex hipbone (compact bone), approximately 3 X 2 cm in size. The specimen had been shellacked on one side and was indicated to have been in a museum drawer in Newcastle, WY for about 100 years (Taylor, 2000) The bone fragment was pressure fractured in half, exposing the inner structure. It was affixed to a metal SEM stub, sputter coated in gold, and viewed at 15kv on a JEOL scanning electron microscope. Low power light micrographs were also made of the unprocessed bone fragments under a dissecting microscope. Recent human hipbone was used as a comparative control. The control bone was acquired from Carolina Biological Supply Co. (Burlington, NC) in a kit of processed human bones for the purposes of anatomical education approximately 20 years ago. According to the supply company (Hardy, 2001), these bones were fixed, cleaned of tissues by maceration, degreased in gasoline and air dried, but were not lacquer coated. They were shipped from India to the U.S. in the 1980s. Additionally, specimens of Moab man (AKA Malachite Man) hipbone were received from Mr. Joe Taylor (Taylor, 1999, p. 62). Moab man human skeletons were discovered in Big Indian Copper mine in 1971 and are considered by some to be intrusional skeletons and not in situ fossils (Berger and Protsch, 1989). These human bone fragments were similarly pressure fractured and processed for electron microscopy as above.
In the dinosaur bone, Haversian bone canal systems (arrows, Figure 1) with their associated lacunae (Figure 2, arrows) are quite visible under low magnification and appear as deep impressions within the bone matrix under higher magnification (Figures 3, 4). Haversian canals contained no remnants of vessels and little loose collagen or other tissues, although their surfaces had a matte appearance. This was due to a carpet of collagen, thus, the calcium phosphate crystalline nature of the bone surface was not visible (Kessel and Kardon, 1979). Canaliculi were also observed along the walls within canals. Lacunae, on the other hand, were often surrounded and filled with large masses of unconsolidated, mummified (or otherwise preserved) fibers, probably polymerized collagen or possibly fibrin (Figures 3, 4, 5). Often there appeared a network of fibers (probably a precursor to the calcium phosphate bone matrix) as seen in Figure 5. Mummified cellular debris, including possible osteocytes, was also found within the bottom of many lacunae (Figure 4, arrows). Canaliculi could be easily seen perforating the lacunae walls and are seen as black dots also surrounding lacunae (Figures 3, 4). It was clearly evident that no mineralization of these collagen fibers had occurred, since well-rounded birfurcations characterized fiber junctions (Figure 6).
Collagen fibers from a fresh human wound scab (Figure 7) and similarly positioned T. rex bone collagen at the same magnification (Figure 8) are remarkably similar. The T. rex collagen appears somewhat shrunken and deformed compared to the human specimen, but in all other respects could pass as recently laid down collagen. In comparison, the Moab man samples seemed devoid of any soft tissue at all. A Haversian system is shown in Figure 9, and there are no fibers associated with the canal, nor were there any fibers or other soft tissues seen in or around lacunae. In addition, when pressure fractured, a minute (12 mm in size) insect exoskeleton (resembling a Springtail of the Order Collembola) was observed, affixed to the surface of a trabecular process in the cancellous bone section of the sample. This exoskeleton, probably the remains of a molt, was lost in processing. If boring insects had access to this Moab man skeletal sample, as have been discovered at other fossil sites in Utah (Hasiotis and Fiorillo, 1997), then this might explain the lack of soft tissue remains in the Moab man samples examined. In stark contrast, however, are the results from the recent human hipbone from the anatomical supply company. Internal bone surfaces were thickly populated with collagen mats while canaliculi showed up well on the inner surfaces of Haversian canals (Figure 10, arrows). In addition to webs of collagen, compressed soft tissues, resembling what might be osteocytes were observed (Figure 11), as well as crenated erythrocytes which were plentiful (Figure 12).
There is also good correlation between dinosaur collagen and human collagen fibers at similar magnifications, which are otherwise indistinguishable (Figures 8 and 12).
Controversy surrounds the Moab man skeletons in several regards. There is general consensus that these remains are unfossilized and that they represent an intrusive aspect to the Dakota sandstone (Cretaceous) rock where they were found and not humans buried in situ (Taylor, 2000; Berger and Protsch, 1989). They have been renamed by Mr. Taylor as Malachite man (Taylor, 1999) due to the bright green patina they display as a result of the high concentration of copper (solution?) from the formation in which they are buried. This green stain was observed to extend almost completely through the compact bone, but it did not extend into the cancellous sections of the bone. The discovery of insect remains inside this bone indicates that they may have been exposed to the elements and to decomposers prior to the infiltration of the copper into the bone matrix, but in any event it seems the copper was not sufficient to preserve collagen fibers. This might explain the lack of soft tissues within the bone as it may have been consumed before any preservation or mummification could have taken place. Preserved human collagen fibers have been found, however, in ancient human remains from Egypt (Hino, Ammitzboll, Moller and Asboe-Hansen, 1982). Even though preservation of collagen and other ultrastructural features were observed (as a result of the embalming process), they were approximately one half normal size and were significantly deformed after only 1700 years postmortem. Alternately, osteocytes have been discovered in a state of perfect preservation within the temporal bone of a 2600-year-old Egyptian mummy, but in this case, the bone was impregnated and preserved by a hard resin polymer (Benitez and Lynn, 1975).
In contrast, the dinosaur specimen exhibits remarkable preservation of soft tissues to the ultrastructural level. The state of preservation in this T. rex bone resembles that of fixed tissues found in recent human bone, thus the preservation, or fossilization process must have immediately followed or have been concurrent with death. It must also have been rapid enough to foil decomposers, but the fine structure of the soft tissue does not exhibit the effects of any mineralization. Additionally, the fact that this level of preservation has remained to this day casts doubts on the time period that may have elapsed between fossilization and the present. The collagen fibers in the dinosaur bone appear to be mummified and not fossilized, therefore they would have been subject to the same sorts of time-related processes that have affected human remains embalmed in Egypt in 100300 A.D (Hino, et. al, 1982). The T. rex specimen examined does not show these age-related effects.
Numerous microscopic structures such as bone lacunae, canaliculi, osteocytes and collagen fibers, protected from the elements deep within bone, have been found under scanning electron microscopy in a T. rex hip bone specimen which has been in a museum for about 100 years. These structures appear to be mummified and were not mineralized by the fossilization process. It is possible that fossilization events might be so rapid that preservation of such structures is guaranteed, and perhaps these specimens are not as old as the literature suggests.
The author thanks Mr. Joe Taylor, curator of Mt. Blanco Fossil Museum, (Crosbyton, TX), for T. rex and Moab man specimens and for his assistance during the project. The author is also indebted to Dr. George Howe and the anonymous reviewers of this paper for critical comments.
CRSQ: Creation Research Society Quarterly
CEN: Creation Ex Nihilo
Benitez, J.T., and G.E Lynn. 1975. Temporal bone studies: findings with uncalcified sections in a 2,600-year- old Egyptian mummy. Journal of Laryngology and Otology 89(6):593599.
Berger, R. and R. Protsch. 1989. UCLA Radiocarbon dates XI. Radiocarbon 31(1):5567
Briggs, D.E.G. 1995. Experimental taphonomy. Palaios 10:539550.
Briggs, D.E.G., and A. Kear. 1993a. Decay of Branchiostoma: implications for soft tissue preservation in conodonts and other primitive chordates. Lethaia 26: 275287.
Briggs, D.E.G., and A. Kear. 1993b. Fossilization of soft tissue in the laboratory. Science 259 (5100):14391442.
Calais, R. 1994. Rapid fossils. CEN 16(3):50.
Froede, C. 1995. Surficial replacement of dinosaur bone by opal in Big Bend National Park, Brewster County, Texas. CRSQ 32(1):11.
Gurley, L.R., J.G. Valdez, W.D. Spall, B.F. Smith, and D.D. Gillette. 1991. Proteins in the fossil bone of the dinosaur Seismosaurus. Journal of Protein Chemistry 10(1): 7590.
Hardy, Alan. 2001. Personal communication.
Hasitosis, S.T., and A. Fiorillo. 1997. Dermestid beetle borings in sauropod and theropod dinosaur bones, Dinosaur National Monument, Utah: keys to the taphonomy of a bone bed. Geological Society of America, Abstracts with Programs 29:13
Helder, M. 1992. Fresh dinosaur bones found. CEN 14(3):1617.
Hino, H., T. Ammitzboll, R. Moller, and G. Asboe-Hansen. 1982. Ultrastructure of skin and hair of an Egyptian mummy. Transmission and scanning electron microscopic observations. Journal of Cutaneous Pathology 9(1):2532
Howe, G.F. 1997. Living bacteria and other living microbes have been isolated from the abdomens of fossil bees thought to be 30 million years old. CRSQ 34(3): 187188.
Kessel. R.G., and R.H. Kardon. 1979. Tissues and organs, a text-atlas of scanning electron microscopy. W.H. Freeman, New York.
Little, K., M. Kelly, and A. Courts. 1962. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 44(B) 503.
Martill, D.M. 1989. The Medusa effect: instantaneous fossilization. Geology Today 5:201205.
Pawlicki, R. 1975. Studies of the fossil dinosaur bone in the scanning electron microscope. Zeitschrift fur Mikroskopiche Anatomiche Forschung. 89(2): 393398.
. 1977a. Histochemical reactions for mucopolysaccharides in the dinosaur bone. Studies on Epon- and methacrylate-embedded semithin sections as well as on isolated osteocytes and ground sections of bone. Acta Histochemica 58(1):7578.
. 1977b. Topochemical localization of lipids in dinosaur bone by means of Sudan B black. Acta Histochemica 59(1):4046.
. 1985. Metabolic pathways of the fossil dinosaur bones, Part V. Folia Histochemica et cytobiologica 23(3):165174.
. 1995. Histochemical demonstration of DNA in osteocytes from dinosaur bones. Folia Histochemica et cytobiologica 33(3):183186.
Pawlicki, H., A. Korbel, and H. Kubiak. 1966. Cells, collagen fibrils and vessels in dinosaur bone. Nature 211(49):655657.
Snelling, A. A. 1998. Exceptional soft tissue preservation in a fossilized dinosaur. Creation Ex Nihilo Technical Journal 12(2):130131.
Taylor, J. 1999. Fossil facts and fantasies. Mt. Blanco Publishing, Crosbyton, TX.
. 2000. Personal communication.
Walker, T. 2000. Petrified flour. CEN 23(1):17.
Weiland, C. 1997a. Sensational dinosaur blood report! CEN 19(4):4243.
. 1997b. Frozen feeding. CEN 19(2):52.
. 1999. Dinosaur bones, just how old are they really? CEN 21(1):5455.
. 2000. The Earth: how old does it look? CEN 23(1):813.